Social inequalities are not always easy to observe or measure. Experiences of discrimination may go unreported, social relationships can create opportunities or reinforce exclusion, and differences in education and occupation between generations do not always tell the whole story of mobility.
Through SAMAM (Discrimination and Development: Caste, Social Capital, and Unequal Mobility in Rural South India), India Institute is examining these questions in collaboration with the Madras Institute of Development Studies and Christ University.
The study covers 386 households across nine villages in rural Tamil Nadu. By interviewing adolescents aged 13–19, their parents and their grandparents, we are able to examine social and economic circumstances, experiences and attitudes across three generations within the same families.
The research combines established measurement instruments, adaptations for the local context, and experimental methods for studying sensitive attitudes.
Discrimination is not always expressed through overt acts of exclusion. It can also take the form of everyday slights, unequal treatment and barriers to opportunity.
SAMAM uses adaptations of the Everyday Discrimination Scale and the Major Experiences of Discrimination measures to document these experiences, with particular attention to caste. We examine how experiences of discrimination differ across social groups and generations, and how they relate to other aspects of people’s lives.
How far have education and occupation changed between grandparents, parents and their children? And do these changes differ across caste and gender groups?
By collecting information on education and occupation across three generations within families, SAMAM examines patterns of intergenerational mobility. The analysis explores where progress has occurred, where disadvantages persist, and the extent to which education has provided a pathway to better opportunities.
People’s opportunities depend not only on their own resources but also on the relationships and networks they can draw upon.
SAMAM examines parents’ social capital through questions about trust, mutual support, community participation and engagement with their children’s schools. Drawing on established social capital measures and questions developed for the study, we explore whether access to social networks and collective support differs across communities, and how these differences relate to educational opportunities and other outcomes.
The Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire (SDQ) is a widely used instrument for assessing emotional and behavioural difficulties among children and adolescents.
SAMAM uses an unusual three-informant approach. Each adolescent completes the SDQ, while a parent and a grandparent independently answer questions about the same adolescent.
This allows us to compare how three generations perceive a young person’s emotional and behavioural wellbeing. We are particularly interested in where their assessments agree, where they differ, and what these differences might tell us about recognising and responding to adolescent distress.
People may be reluctant to express views about caste that they believe others would disapprove of. Direct survey questions may therefore fail to capture the extent of certain attitudes.
SAMAM uses list experiments, an indirect questioning method, alongside direct survey questions to examine attitudes towards caste hierarchy, social distance, equality and the continuation of caste practices.
The list experiments allow us to estimate how widespread particular attitudes are within groups without requiring respondents to disclose their individual position on sensitive statements. We also examine how these attitudes vary across generations and social groups.
An important strength of SAMAM is the opportunity to examine these different aspects of social life within the same study.
The data allow us to investigate relationships between caste, education, occupational mobility, experiences of discrimination, social capital and adolescent mental health. The list experiments provide a complementary picture of attitudes that may not be fully captured through direct questioning.
Taken together, these approaches offer a more detailed understanding of how inequality persists or changes across generations, and of the possible pathways through which social disadvantage affects people’s lives.
Data collection for SAMAM has been completed, and the research has moved into analysis, writing and dissemination. Three research papers have reached the draft stage, with further analyses and publications in progress. The findings have also been discussed at an authors’ workshop and expert roundtables involving academics, practitioners and government officials.
The project will produce academic papers and other research outputs examining different dimensions of inequality and their relationships across generations. Research instruments and supporting methodological documentation will be made available where appropriate.
For more information about the study, its methodology, research team, activities and publications, visit the SAMAM project website.